Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah Surrogacy in justice for Attorney-General Abdul Gani Patail

On the Federal Court ruling today, Anwar  said it now meant that even Karpal Singh could prosecute Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad as conflict of interest was no longer an issue.


Cynicism is never irrational. The irrational, often wrong, sometimes right, are impelled by instinct, heart or even conscience. Cynics are morality-proof. They prefer data to truth Mere Mockery of a Trial’:dramatic work in which highly improbable plot situations, exaggerated characters, and often slapstick elements are used for humorous effect

Abdul Gani Patail: never doubted his ability, decision  runs according to script Justice is about Mahathir's posturing 

ganipatail

Beyond the rule of law Protecting the undeserving

A TRUE LIFE INJECTED WITH INTENSE PASSION, IS THE LIFE LESSONF MAHATHIR MOHAMAD TO ESCAPE SCAM.CREATE ANOTHER SCAM EVIDENCE OF CRIMINAL WRONGDOING BY ATTORNEY-GENERAL TAN SRI ABDUL GANI PATAIL IF THERE IS A QUESTION MARK OVER THE ABILITY OF THE AG, THE PM CAN ASK HIM TO RESIGN AND “IF THERE IS ANY WRONG DOING BY GANI, THE PM CAN ADVICE THE KING TO SET UP A TRIBUNAL TO TRY THE AG”.SCAM AS THEAT REMat Zain has been “consistent” with his allegations.

urging for a probe on allegations against Gani, and for a tribunal to be set up should sufficient evidence be obtained.
With the revelation of the meeting and the allegations against Gani “it seems that the AG is facing a trial in the media”, said Ahmad Zamri. And he went on to say, therefore the government must open a thorough investigation by re-looking into the “various police and MACC reports made against the AG in the past”.
To be fair, comments made by Ahmad Zamri as well as Abu Talib, were made before news of Mat Zain’s Batu Puteh allegations broke where the former Kuala Lumpur CID chief called for the setting up of a RCI More politicians have been granted  the state of being protected. why does the state need to provide him with such high level Protection.
PAS Youth’s Ahmad Zamri Asa’ad Khuzaimi, said considering the people who attended the meeting with Mahathir “it appears that the revelation to the media is to put pressure on Gani and his boss Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak”.why is Mahathir involved? Is he “going after Gani”?  former PM and the AG enjoy good relations. but now”out to get” the AG someone stepping on someone’s toes.So A-G Gani Patail  stepping on Mahathir toes.There’s also this talk of the AG becoming too powerful for the powerful – thus this “attempt to get rid of him”. Again, nothing to back it up as to who ‘the powerful’ are and what big cases are being pursued. with evidence of criminal wrong doing by the AG Mahathir  must be responsible enough to lodge police reports and stand by the allegations, said Abu Talib
 if there is a question mark over the ability of the AG, the PM can ask him to resign and “if there is any wrong doing by Gani, the PM can advice the King to set up a tribunal to try the AG”. we respond to scams only when they come in recognisable packaging, neatly labelled and accompanied by clear instructions on usage. The anger around corruption is misleading, for it hides the extent to which it has come to be accepted as a routine part of our lives.We always knew that there were people like A-G Gani Patail, and we always accepted that when one goes, another will take his place. Had the whole issue been uncovered as a scam, and had it involved a specific and prominent political personality, it would have made for some diversion, but what we have here is a simply some more commonplace reality. Here all that emerges is that the system itself is fundamentally flawed, and that is something that is not interesting enoughBeyond the rule of law Protecting the undeserving A true life injected with intense passion, is the life lessonf MAHATHIR MOHAMAD TO ESCAPE SCAM.CREATE another scam evidence of criminal wrongdoing by Attorney-General Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail if there is a question mark over the ability of the AG, the PM can ask him to resign and “if there 

So what do you think Attorney General  is  made of? The zeal to help, to uplift the judiciary, to learn governance if they haven’t, and proclaim publicly that it is not for the lust of power? No it is for self-serving goals, loyalties for sheer benefit, clubbing on to an ideology so as to move down the dissenters. Do we play for the game, or do we play rather aggressively for our own innings?  Both, you may say, but if it comes to elimination of one of the two, self-serving goals are preferred, perhaps wiser.Democracy, in its conceptual principles gives one the right to choose, but disturbingly from the lot that is already chosen. Can’t say that money, muscle and manipulation do not go in all that, and putting it bluntly, why should one who has all this not use it for his purpose? The answer is that he probably would, if he found someone more deserving. No harm at all in believing we all are immortals, because when the inevitable happened, no one came back to say, just to say that it was indeed not so.What comes around goes around Best option is for him is to resign or sue Mat Zain

This treason of the highest order an unforgiveable betrayal of trust voters reposed in themThis has been morally degrading and has turned politics predatorySHAFEE FRAMED AND FABRICATED THE SODOMY1AND 2 NOW WANTS BE SODOMISED A LIABILITY TO NAJIB

Gani, squeeze najib’s balls harder and the matter would be put to restt Silence is golden for all. Najib will do nothing since AG has Najib’s marbles in his hand on many issues including Altantuyu & submarine controversy. 
a nation led by thieves and plunderersEx-Attorney-General Talib should aim his questions to not only Gani, his successor, but also the Government led by Datu Seri Najib. ” Elegant silence ” on the part of all Ministers and AG is not an option. The loss of territory, Pulau Batu Puteh , is of national interest, urgent and important. The poor show at the International Court of Justice is a shame. How could our leaders treat this sovereignty of Pulau Batu Puteh so very lightly? And most surprisingly, the Home Minister requires a Police Report while the SD is a sworn statement by ex-CId man! Is the HM trying to erase the issue from the public domain? Undoubtedly, this is a hot potato; nobody like sto touch it! But the peopel of Malaysia, and especially teh HRH the Sulktan of Johore, have a strong interest By calling the AG by the ex-AG is barking up the wrong tree! He should have directed the issue to the PM .Talk to the father, and not the son o r the servant, please! Note that you could not hookwink the ICJ ! MPs speak out. Why are they so silence? Does it means treason is accepted to all BN representatives? Malaysians have to remember this when the vote in future


Sometimes you do not realise you are in the midst of a vast silence till it is pierced through with sound. Often, you may not notice noise until it ends abruptly and silence prevails. You may not notice how dark it is till a light is flicked on. Sometimes you do not know how agitated you have been, till a caressing hand calms you. The absence of some people makes you realise the significance of their presence.Mat Zain accuses  Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah   of being LIAR, FABRICATOR and MANIPULATOR
the man who is the real mastermind behind this latest conspiracy to frame Anwar is Shafee Abdullah. Just days before the sodomy allegation exploded, and even before Saiful’s meeting with Rodwan on 25 June 2008, Shafee was in Najib’s house to attend a gathering. And in front of scores of witnesses he asked to be excused early because he ‘had a very big fish to catch’. Shafee conveniently made it known that he is behind the move to catch the ‘big fish’ and he wanted all those in Najib’s house to be aware that Najib was in the know. Actually, Najib did not know what he was talking about and assumed that the ‘big fish’ meant Raja Petra Kamarudin and was with regards to the Statutory Declaration that he had signed just days earlier on 18 June 2008.
Shafee was supposed to have led the prosecution against Anwar. A provision in the law called FIAT allows the Attorney-General to appoint an outsider to conduct the prosecution. If Shafee does well then he would most likely be appointed the next Attorney-General. When word got out that he is heading the special police operations centre, which was located in his office, they had to abandon the whole idea.
Shafee’s hands are behind the whole thing. And this can only happen with Abdullah’s blessing. No, it is not Mahathir who is behind this. And it is not Abdullah, Najib and Anwar who are the three victims. The victims are Mahathir, Najib and Anwar. Abdullah is the hidden hand and Shafee is the henchman who was tasked with the job of implementing the evil deed. Politics is not what it always appears to be in Malaysia
This treason of the highest order an unforgiveable betrayal of trust voters reposed in themThis has been morally degrading and has turned politics predatory. But things still remained functional. Till prosperity threw up a body of people whose progress in life has little to do with state patronage and who thus resent being subjected to poor governance and extortion.


WHY ARE THE BLOODY MPS KEEPING. THIS TREASON OF THE HIGHEST ORDER AN UNFORGIVEABLE BETRAYAL OF TRUST VOTERS REPOSED IN THEMTHIS HAS BEEN MORALLY DEGRADING AND HAS TURNED POLITICS PREDATORY. BUT THINGS STILL REMAINED FUNCTIONAL. TILL PROSPERITY THREW UP A BODY OF PEOPLE WHOSE PROGRESS IN LIFE HAS LITTLE TO DO WITH STATE PATRONAGE AND WHO THUS RESENT BEING SUBJECTED TO POOR GOVERNANCE AND EXTORTION.

Any institution, whether party or government, demands the stability of an uncontroversial script, or the comfort of silence from geniuses who can never find an equitable balance between their self-estimation is a sharp and well-read politician, except when his tongue goes to his head. He has been a good , a former transport minister,, willing to stand his ground and even take a risk or two

A severe, trite, authentic case made by a journalist not just from your fraternity but from your office, the office that for over 12 years has been emblematic of unflinching, investigative journalism is mulled over at a pace that defies your very etymological origin  is this your way of acting correctly?Neither one of you has offered any rationale about why your office does not  examines cases  which is mandated by  Court judgment in correct correct correct  case. How have you acted correctly?Your statement – that you “need time prioritize it,” – does not even make sense – for prioritizing it would mean acting without lapse in time – self contradictory statements such as this have the media, and the ever watchful readership waiting in abeyance while you prioritize, or rather think about acting correctly!If you are, as you say, ‘driven by what she wants’ then how can you follow it up with a statement such as, “(he) stepped down. It was something had not asked for. It was much more than what she wanted.” How sardonically heroic for to give  so much more – a self-contrived temporary vacation to get away from the eye of the storm – for what he ‘in his correct senses’ deems as ‘drunken banter’ and a ‘lapse of judgment’ the Attorney General  should read and understand Article 145(3) of the Malaysian Constitution Unholy Trinity of Mahathir, the AG and the MACC  Attorney-General Abdul Gani Patail for malicious prosecution.
. But collective responsibility demands caution: you have to keep space between your blow-drier and your brain.Mahathir  may even have been right , but he was wrong to say what was right.Despite his penchant for the unusual,Dr Ling, a former transport minister, has been a far more careful politician, sticking to his responsibilities at some cost to his individuality.
Tun Dr Ling Liong Sik spoke with passion rather than anger, with force and with seeming conviction. He sought to communicate a new commitment to change the party and its working, so as to build a more empowered India that stays true to its tradition of respect for diversity instead of straying into the majoritarian bylanes to darkness.which required better acting from the irrepressible. Politics is carbon-dated by events, not time.Mahathir Partnerships need tensile strength to survive misunderstandings when suspicion warps a relationship into a tangential curve. Mercury rather than blood flows through the vein of public life; politics is very human and turbulent, and ego floats beyond the reach of rational discourse.Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail brought charges against Dr Ling and another former transport minister, Tan Sri Chan Kong Choy, for cheating the government over the PKFZ project. Both were later acquitted.said it before and Tun Dr Ling Liong Sik say it again- AG Gani Patail is a liability to this government
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has once again failed to stop Umno lawyer Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah (pic) from leading the prosecution in Putrajaya's appeal in his sodomy acquittal.
A five-man Federal Court bench led by Tan Sri Zulkefli Ahmad Makinuddin said Datuk Mat Zain Ibrahim's statutory declaration was an out of court statement and could not be accepted.
"The rest of the allegation in the SD is hotly disputed," he said of the unanimous decision.
The public prosecutor's appeal has been scheduled before the Court of Appeal tomorrow.As such, he said, Anwar has not made a prima facie case against Shafee.
However, Anwar has filed an application to recall investigating officer Jude Balacious Pereira following the findings of the Human Rights Commission (Suhakam) that the former cop was not a truthful witness in a human rights case five years ago.
The Suhakam inquiry which found Pereira to be an untruthful witness was chaired by then commissioner Shafee , who coincidentally is the lead prosecutor.
One of Anwar's lawyer's Sivarasa Rasiah said the Court of Appeal would have to decide on the application before the appeal was heard.
On the Federal Court ruling today, Anwar (pic, left) said it now meant that even Karpal Singh could prosecute Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad as conflict of interest was no longer an issue.
"But of course we will not do it even if Pakatan Rakyat comes to power.
"I am disappointed but will shoulder on and return tomorrow to fight another battle," said a calm and composed Anwar.
He said the decision today showed it was difficult to challange a lawyer who he said was Umno's stooge.
Anwar pointed out that Shafee had fought him tooth and nail in previous cases, but the court did not take this into account.
Earlier Shafee argued that Anwar's application to disqualify him must be thrown out as it heavily relied on Mat Zain's statutory declaration (SD), which he described as hearsay and having no value.
Shafee, who submitted in his capacity as Deputy Public Prosecutor (DPP), called Mat Zain a "rumour monger".
"Mat Zain is a rumour monger. This proceeding is to determine whether I am fit and proper person as DPP. So , the content of the SD is merely hearsay and not admissible in court," he said in rebutting Anwar's appeal to disqualify him.
Attorney General Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail appointed Shafee as ad hoc DPP last July to lead the prosecution's appeal to set aside the sodomy acquittal of Anwar.
Shafee said Mat Zain should have affirmed an affidavit in support of Anwar's application so that the public prosecutor would have an opportunity to cross examine him.
"Mat Zain was screaming outside the court but was not prepared to come to the court. He did everything dishonestly and dishonourably."
He said the Court of Appeal which dismissed Anwar's application on December 20 was correct in its observation that the SD centred around the 1998 black eye incident.
Saying Anwar was barking up the wrong tree, Shafee said he should have written to Gani to stop him (Shafee) from remaining as DPP.
"The AG has unfettered discretion under the Federal Constitution who he wants to appoint as DPP," he said, adding that the court had no power to disqualify him.
He added that he had no animosity with Anwar and that as a lawyer, he had acted for and against Umno and its leaders on a case to case basis.
He said there would only be conflict of interest if he had conducted the sodomy trial.
Anwar's lawyer Tommy Thomas submitted that Shafee must be disqualified since there was overwhelming evidence of conflict of interest.
Thomas said Shafee should be barred from taking up this case because as a lawyer, he would also be in breach of the Legal Profession (Practice and Etiquette) Rules 1978.
Anwar, 66, was acquitted by the High Court on January 9 last year, on a charge of sodomising his former aide Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan at a condominium unit in Bukit Damansara in 2008.
In his second attempt to disqualify Shafee, Anwar said Shafee was not a fit and proper person to be a DPP due to the revelation in Mat Zain's SD.
Mat Zain in his 31-page SD said he and Shafee, as well as former Commercial Crime Investigation Department director Datuk Ramli Yusof, had met Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad last year, where they allegedly discussed Gani's wrongdoing.
On December 20, Datuk Aziah Ali, who led the three-man Court of Appeal, dismissed Anwar's application, saying the SD was irrelevant as it was related to the "black eye" incident which was already concluded.
Aziah argued that the SD was hearsay evidence and that Mat Zain was not available to ascertain the truth, adding that there were latent defects in the SD such as the blotting out of Mat Zain's identity card number and address.
Anwar had first challenged the legality of Shafee's appointment under the Criminal Procedure Code. This was dismissed by the Federal Court on November 20. - February 11, 2014

No comments:

Post a Comment